Since Nightingale is a fork of Songbird, we were using Songbird langpacks.
Now that we are working more deeply on the software, we feel we need our own localization system.
Songbird currently uses a custom Ruby web platform hosted at translate.songbirdnest.com
to allow contributors to translate strings, but there are lot of issues :
- The website is not open sourced and hasn’t evolved in a long time
- Translations are never frozen, meaning everybody can edit the current locales
- There are no real teams for localization, a Google group songbird-l10n was created to attempt fixing this but it was abandoned
- Some locales are absent
- Some langpacks don’t include Mozilla strings, meaning preferences interface, download windows, etc. will be in English
- The platform is unable to export langpacks without missing strings (they are replaced by en-US strings instead)
- No clear changelog for each locale
The localizations themselves also have some issues :
- Some strings are no longer used but are still proposed for translation, some are duplicates
- “Songbird” is still present in places (instead of brandShortName)
- Some specific symbols/punctuation characters are not respected (ellipsis)
- Some strings refer to closed source add-ons
- There are only 4 files to cover all localizations (while Firefox uses ~50 files, depending on the window or feature)
Good points in the localizations:
- The en-US source files weren’t touched for 1 year, so we don’t have to deal with including recent changes
- Lots of locales are already 100 % completed
- Some unimplemented features already have strings ready like Podcasts or Equalizer presets
- The langpack download system is already working well with Nightingale
Who are the translators ?
Some translators were Mozilla contributors, so it’s easy to contact them, though most of them gave up, because Linux support was dropped.
For the next version of Nightingale, we want to fix all these issues by handling the localizations on the Babelzilla
Babelzilla fixes many issues :
- It will soon be open sourced since Mozilla add-ons developers use it
- It’s much more powerful, and is able to import/export data
- It allows team work, frozen strings, fixed release dates…
- Many more locales are covered
- Translators can easily contact each other
- A topic is created to cover each translation
- We have much more control on the entire process
Aside from Babelzilla, we will also store locales in our GitHub repo
so we can keep track of what’s changed. Scripts will be added to easily build langpacks out of source files.
An attempt was done in the past to use Babelzilla to fix the French localization in Songbird, and it was helpful in comparison to POTI’s translations website. As part of the French community I was also able to meet with most of the contributors – a real plus when working on a project like this.
Moreover, we are choosing this platform because it’s already known by add-ons translators/developers and because of friendship with people who are running it.
If you want to help, you can look at opened issues here on GitHub :
You don’t necessarily need to know how to code to help us clean up the current localizations. If you want to help translate, pick up your language skills and try to contact the past Songbird localizers! 🙂
We also want to know what localization strings add-ons developers need – we will try to gather data on which are the most used, and if it’s worth including them directly in the application.
Like before, we are contributing back all of our changes to Songbird, and you can check this metabug
which covers our Songbird patches.
We really want Songbird to take a look at our clean-up proposition since it helps a lot of the translators and also improves performance (Loading smaller files instead of a big file with all of the strings).
We also want to reduce compatibility breakage for add-ons developers. It means we will not change string ID’s – we’ll also provide documentation on how to best support both apps in the same add-on.
Thanks for reading, and if you have any questions feel free to ask in comments, forums
or over IRC !
-GeekShadow and the Nightingale Team